Suing Insurance Company for Fair Treatment

Insurance is supposed to provide peace of mind, but what happens when an insurance company fails to honor its commitments? 

Whether it’s denying a valid claim without reason, delaying payments, or offering unfair settlements, these actions can leave policyholders feeling frustrated and helpless. Fortunately, insurance providers can be held accountable when they act in bad faith or fail to meet their legal obligations.

Understanding your rights as a policyholder is the first step in protecting yourself. Large insurance companies have teams of lawyers working to minimize payouts, but that doesn’t mean you have to accept their decisions without question. With the right legal representation, you can recover compensation for damages, fight for a fair settlement, and make sure the insurance company is held accountable for its actions.

Understanding Your Rights Against Insurance Providers

Insurance providers are legally required to treat policyholders fairly and handle claims in good faith. When an insurance company acts unfairly - whether by delaying payments, denying a valid claim, or refusing to investigate - it may be violating its legal obligations. Understanding your rights is important to determining when to take action and hold the insurance company accountable.

When Can You Take Action?

There are certain circumstances where filing a lawsuit against an insurance company is justified. These include:

• Denial of a Valid Claim: If your insurance provider denies your claim without a valid reason, you may have grounds to sue.
• Unreasonable Delays: Failing to process a claim within a reasonable timeframe can indicate bad faith behavior.
• Low Settlement Offers: Offering far less than the actual value of your damages may violate policy coverage and lead to legal action.
• Failure to Investigate: An insurance company is required to properly investigate claims before rejecting them. Negligence in this process can justify a lawsuit.

Obligations of Insurance Companies

An insurance company must:

1. Honor Policy Terms: Provide coverage for incidents outlined in the insurance policy.
2. Act in Good Faith: Evaluate claims fairly and without intentional delays or denials.
3. Pay Valid Claims Promptly: Deliver payments owed to policyholders without forcing unnecessary disputes.
4. Provide Reasonable Explanations: Clearly explain why a valid claim is denied or delayed.

What Is Bad Faith Behavior?

Bad faith occurs when an insurance company intentionally avoids fulfilling its obligations. This may include:

• Ignoring evidence that supports your claim
• Refusing to communicate about the process or settlement offers
• Misrepresenting policy terms or policy coverage
• Threatening policyholders to discourage them from pursuing claims

If you believe your insurance company breached its duty to you, it may be time to seek legal representation to recover compensation and protect your rights.

Get Help Today

Steps to Take Before Suing

Taking legal action against an insurance company is a big step, so it’s important to be prepared. Before filing a lawsuit, follow these steps to strengthen your case and improve your chances of recovering compensation.

1. Review Your Insurance Policy

Start by carefully reading your insurance policy to understand what’s covered and what isn’t. Pay attention to the fine print, including policy coverage limits, exclusions, and deadlines for filing claims. If the insurance company denies your valid claim, make sure you can prove that it falls within your coverage.

2. Document All Communication

Keep detailed records of every interaction with the insurance provider and insurance agents. Save emails, letters, and phone call logs. Written proof can help show whether the insurance company has acted in bad faith or violated the terms of your policy coverage.

3. Gather Evidence

Evidence is significant to proving your claim. Collect:

• Medical records for physical harm or injuries related to a car accident
• Repair estimates or bills for property damage
• Witness statements and photos documenting the incident
• Copies of settlement offers and any unreasonable delays or bad faith behavior

The stronger your evidence, the easier it is to demonstrate that the insurance company breached its contract.

4. Send a Demand Letter

Before filing a lawsuit, many attorneys recommend sending a demand letter to the insurance provider. This formal notice outlines:

• Details about your claim and why you’re entitled to compensation
• Evidence supporting your valid claim
• A request for a fair settlement within a specified timeframe

A demand letter shows the insurance company you’re serious and may resolve the issue without needing to go to court.

5. Consult an Insurance Attorney

If the insurance company still refuses to act fairly, it’s time to consult an attorney. Working with a law firm experienced in insurance disputes ensures you’ll have someone to answer questions, handle negotiations, and guide you through the legal process. The insurance coverage attorneys at Muller Brazil work on a contingency fee basis, so you won’t pay legal fees unless your case is successful.

Contact Us Now

Types of Damages You Can Seek

When an insurance company fails to honor its obligations, you may be entitled to financial compensation for the harm you’ve suffered. Damages can cover everything from property damage to emotional distress caused by the insurance company’s bad faith behavior. Here’s a breakdown of the types of damages you can seek in a lawsuit.

Compensatory Damages

Compensatory damages are meant to reimburse policyholders for actual financial losses caused by the insurance provider. These can include:

• Medical Expenses: Bills for treating physical harm after a car accident or other incident.
• Property Damage: Repair or replacement costs for damaged property covered by the insurance policy.
• Lost Wages: Income lost if injuries or delays caused by the insurance company prevent you from working.

Consequential Damages

These damages cover additional losses caused by the insurance company’s negligence. For example:

• Loss of Business Income: If delayed payments prevented you from operating your business.
• Reputation Damage: If the insurer’s failure to pay harmed your credibility or relationships.

Emotional Distress Damages

Dealing with bad faith behavior can lead to emotional suffering. Courts may award damages for:

• Anxiety and Stress: The mental toll of prolonged battles with an insurance provider.
• Depression or PTSD: Emotional trauma resulting from delays or unfair settlement offers.

Punitive Damages

Punitive damages are designed to hold insurance companies accountable for bad faith practices and deter future misconduct. These damages go beyond compensating for losses and instead punish the insurance company for intentional wrongdoing, such as:

• Misrepresenting policy coverage
• Denying a valid claim without investigation
• Offering extremely low settlement offers

Attorney’s Fees and Court Costs

In some cases, you may also recover attorney’s fees and court costs related to pursuing your lawsuit. This guarantees you’re not left with legal fees after holding the insurance company responsible.

Speak to us Now

Common Defenses Used by Insurance Companies

When an insurance company faces a lawsuit, it often uses specific defenses to avoid paying compensation or to minimize liability. Understanding these tactics can help you and your lawyer prepare to counter them effectively.

Lack of Coverage: An insurance company may claim that your policy coverage does not apply to the specific damages in question. This defense often hinges on technicalities in the insurance policy, such as exclusions or missed deadlines.

How to Respond:

• Review your insurance policy carefully to confirm your coverage.
• Use the demand letter and gather evidence to show that your claim falls within the terms of the contract.

Breach of Contract by the Policyholder: Insurers might argue that the policyholder failed to meet their obligations, such as not paying premiums on time, providing incomplete information, or missing deadlines to file the claim.

How to Respond:

• Provide proof of payments, notices, and compliance with policy requirements.
• Demonstrate that any errors were minor and did not affect the valid claim.

Proximate Cause Disputes: In some cases, insurance companies dispute whether the damages claimed were directly caused by the incident covered under the policy coverage. For example, they may suggest property damage resulted from wear and tear rather than a covered event.

How to Respond:

• Present documentation, expert opinions, and photos to prove the proximate cause of your damages.
• Highlight evidence of negligence or bad faith behavior during the investigation.

Lowball Settlement Offers: Many large insurance companies offer settlements far below the actual value of a claim, hoping policyholders will accept out of frustration.

How to Respond:

• Work with an insurance attorney to negotiate a fair settlement and push back against low offers.
• Be prepared to file a lawsuit if negotiations fail.

Blaming the Policyholder: Insurers sometimes attempt to shift responsibility to the policyholder by alleging fraud, false statements, or failure to properly resolve damages.

How to Respond:

• Provide a paper trail of gathered evidence and communications to refute false claims.
• Highlight any bad faith behavior or delay tactics used by the insurance provider.

Contact Us Now

Holding Insurance Companies Accountable

When an insurance company fails to honor its promises, it’s important to take action and hold them accountable for bad faith behavior or negligence. Filing a lawsuit can help you recover compensation for financial losses, property damage, and emotional distress while making sure insurance providers follow the law.

Why Accountability Matters

• Protects Policyholders’ Rights: Enforces policy coverage and prevents unfair practices.
• Deters Bad Faith Practices: Courts can impose punitive damages to discourage misconduct.
• Secures Financial Recovery: Lawsuits provide compensation for damages and legal fees.

When to Take Action

Legal action may be necessary if an insurance provider:

• Denies a valid claim without a valid reason
• Engages in bad faith behavior, such as delays or unfair settlement offers
• Refuses to pay what’s owed under the insurance policy

Ready to Fight for Fair Treatment?

Taking on an insurance company can feel exhausting, especially when dealing with bad faith behavior, unfair settlement offers, or a valid claim that’s been wrongfully denied. However, insurance companies are not above the law and with the right legal representation, you can hold them accountable and fight for the financial compensation you're entitled to.

At Muller Brazil, we specialize in helping policyholders who have been treated unfairly. Whether you’re facing property damage, emotional distress, or need to recover compensation for financial losses, our team is here to guide you through the process.

We work on a contingency fee basis, so you won’t pay legal fees unless we win your case. Contact us today for a free consultation at 215.885.1655 or info@mullerbrazil.com and let us help you get the fair treatment you deserve.

Get Help Today